The historical factors behind Africa's economic underdevelopment have long intrigued economists and historians alike. While the continent's colonial past often takes centre stage, one researcher, Harvard economist, Nathan Nunn, delved deeper into the impact of the transatlantic slave trade on Africa's present-day economic plight.
His findings shed light on a compelling correlation between the extent of the slave trade and the economic struggles faced by African nations today.
Africa, is, undisputedly, the poorest continent on Earth. 33 of the African continent's 54 countries*, are some of the world's least developed countries (LCDs) (2021). While this lack of development, with its high levels of poverty, is more than double that of the rest of the world combined, it cannot be solely attributed to colonisation. If this were true, the economies of India, and South America would also be expected to be preforming more poorly in terms of GDP growth. * (Some argue that the number is 56, including two disputed areas, namely Somalia and Western Sahara).
Since the late 1800s, many European imperial powers have invaded and exploited African nations, impeding their economic development. However, the slave trade holds a unique place in Africa's history, predating colonialism and inflicting its own profound impact.
Nunn formulated a hypothesis, suggesting that '..the countries most affected by the slave trade would be the ones facing greater poverty and underdevelopment today..'
To test this hypothesis, Nunn turned to a comprehensive database detailing thousands of slave trade voyages from Africa, meticulously compiled by historians. By calculating the number of slaves shipped from different regions across Africa, Nathan could begin to investigate his hypothesis empirically.
While the data supplied insights, a challenge remained. The origin of the slaves did not always align with the countries from which they were shipped. Slaves were often transported long distances, making it crucial to find their ethnicity and decide their coastal or inland origins. Nunn diligently scoured historical records, including sale records, fugitive slave lists, court records, and runaway notices, to collect the necessary ethnicity data.
Archives in Zanzibar, Tanzania proved to be a valuable resource for understanding the slave trades beyond the transatlantic route.
Armed with this data, Nunn could finally explore whether the countries most affected by the slave trade experienced greater economic struggles today. Plotting the information on a chart comparing the log number of slaves taken from a given area with the log real GDP per capita, a clear trend appeared.
Namibia, with a relatively small slave trade history, displayed a higher average income compared to other African nations. In contrast, Nigeria, greatly impacted by the slave trade, showcased a relatively lower average income. The correlation between the extent of the slave trade and lower levels of wealth became clear.
Source: cepr.org
So, what is going on from an economics student's point of view? To understand the underlying mechanism of Nunn’s hypothesis, it appears that those countries exploited more by the slave trade suffered from lower levels of trust.
Africans were not solely enslaved by European slave traders - there was also a considerable involvement of Africans in the enslavement of their own people.
The enslavement of fellow Africans eroded interpersonal trust, which severely hindered stability within those countries affected by slavery. This lack of trust created an environment where economic growth became increasingly challenging.
Property rights serve as a crucial pillar in the foundation of advanced economies. The ability for individuals and organisations to own private property incentivises hard work and cuts the risk of theft. However, in many African countries, the absence or limited nature of property rights poses significant constraints on economic development. The general lack of trust emerging from slavery encourages corruption and weakens the spread and acceptance of property rights, which in turn hinders economic progress.
In societies where property rights are limited or absent, the motivation to invest in and improve the quality of land diminishes. Without the assurance of secure ownership, individuals have little incentive to develop or cultivate land, as they face the risk of being dispossessed or having their efforts go unrewarded. This lack of trust in property rights stifles agricultural productivity and inhibits the growth of the rural economy.
Beyond the impact on property rights, the absence of trust in African economies has far-reaching implications for development. Several non-economic factors, such as political stability, corruption, and conflict, are deeply intertwined with trust and have a direct impact on economic growth.
A stable political environment, characterised by good governance and the absence of war and conflict, plays a vital role in stimulating economic growth. When institutions and corporations run within a stable and predictable framework, business and consumer confidence thrive. Investors are more willing to commit capital, both domestically and through foreign direct investment (FDI). Furthermore, a stable political climate reduces capital flight, enabling resources to remain within the country and contribute to higher savings ratios. Trust in institutions, organisations and corporations appears a necessary condition for economic development.
Trust is the bedrock of any effort to combat corruption effectively. In nations where trust in institutions is lacking, corruption flourishes. The diversion of public resources, bribery, and nepotism impede economic progress and undermine public trust in the government and business sectors. Corruption erodes investor confidence and hampers domestic and international investments, diverting resources away from productive activities and into the hands of a few.
The absence of trust creates a vicious cycle that perpetuates underdevelopment. Weak property rights, fuelled by a lack of trust, stifle investment and hinder economic growth. Simultaneously, corruption thrives in an environment of limited trust, further eroding property rights and hampering development. This interplay between trust, property rights, and corruption becomes a self-reinforcing cycle that is difficult to break.
Recognising the critical role of trust is essential for African economies to overcome these challenges. Building trust requires a multifaceted approach that addresses institutional reforms, transparency, and accountability.
Governments need to prioritise political stability, strengthen legal frameworks, and ensure the protection of property rights. Efforts to combat corruption should be intensified, fostering an environment where trust can flourish. By actively nurturing trust, African nations can attract investments, foster entrepreneurship, and promote economic growth.
Establishing secure property rights and combating corruption will not only unlock the economic potential within these countries but also create a solid foundation for sustainable development and improved living standards.
