In the short run, increasing the input of variable factors gives rise to 'returns in the short run'. These returns can be increasing, constant, or diminishing. Economic theory predicts that returns in the short run will eventually diminish, with an upturn in the marginal costs of production. But what happens in the long run?
In the long run, all factors of production are variable, and none are fixed. When a firm moves into its long run it does so by increasing its scale of production. This means that all factors are increased - more labour and capital and increases in all other factor inputs.
For example, if a restaurant owner in one district of a town or city decides to open a second restaurant across town, then it has entered its long run and is increasing the scale of its operations. If over the next 5 years it opens five more restaurants, we can measure its 'returns' to scale at each point of expansion.
This is done by measuring the output - in meals produced per week - as restaurants are added. We can measure total output (in meals), average output per restaurant, and marginal output [the additional meals from adding each new restaurant]. For convenience, each restaurant is referred to as one unit of expansion - each new restaurant means increases in all the factors.
As is shown below, the output in relation to inputs starts to increase at first, becomes constant, and then diminishes (commonly referred to as decreasing returns to scale to avoid confusions with diminishing returns to variable factors in the short run.
| Restaurants | Total meals | Average meals | Marginal meals |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 |
| 2 | 2400 | 1200 | 1400 |
| 3 | 4000 | 1333 | 1600 |
| 4 | 5600 | 1400 | 1600 |
| 5 | 7000 | 1400 | 1400 |
| 6 | 8200 | 1367 | 1200 |
The onset of decreasing returns to scale starts first with marginal returns. In this case, meals in the fourth restaurant are 1600 per week, and in the fifth the number drops to 1400 - hence decreasing returns sets in with the addition of the fifth restaurant.
Changes in returns to change reflect the impact of economies and diseconomies of scale.
Economies of scale are the gains that firms can make in terms of reducing production costs as a result of expansion and which are unavailable to smaller firms.
As firm’s grow, they move into the long run. From a firm’s point of view, the long run refers to a situation when all of the firm’s factors of production can be increased – in other words, all factors are variable and none are fixed. In contrast, the short run is defined as a situation where output can be increased by using more variable factors and where at least one factor of production remains fixed.
19th Century English economist, Alfred Marshall1, provides the first attempt to describe and classify the gains derived from expansion. He argued that they arise from ‘economy of skill, economy of specialised machinery, and economy of materials’ as firms increase their scale of production.
According to Marshall these gains could either arise from ‘the general development of an industry’, which he called external economies – or from those ‘dependent on the resources of individual businesses and the efficiency of their management’, which he called internal economies.
Internal economies of scale are those that arise when a single firm expands its scale of operations. Many of these are associated with increased specialisation resulting from larger scale. Examples of these include:
Internal economies of scale reduce average costs and hence provide benefits to the firm, examples including:
External economies of scale are gains that are potentially available to all firms in an industry when the industry itself grows. Examples include:
The LRAC curve is derived by tracking the changes in average cost that result from increases in the scale of a firm’s operations. As can be seen in the following hypothetical example, adding new plants results in lower short run cost structures until eventually short run costs begin to rise again.
We can derive the LRAC from drawing a line of tangent to the short run curves, as shown: