Agricultural markets, especially those in the More Economically Developed Countries (MEDCs), are characterised by a high degree of government intervention. This is because agricultural markets are usually unstable, suffer from price volatility, and are strategically important to provide the country with food security.
The price volatility within agricultural markets is largely due to both supply and demand being unresponsive to price changes - that is, price inelastic - as shown in the diagram below.
Furthermore, supply of agricultural products is susceptible to changes in the weather and other random supply shocks.
Food prices are also an important contributor to inflation and, along with beverages, make up between 12% and 16% of the CPI baskets in the UK (12%) USA (14%) and the EU (16%). This excludes spending in restaurants and on hotels.
There are three main types of government intervention in agricultural markets:
We look at each in turn.
Deficiency payments were a key part of the UK's agricultural policy from 1947 to 1973. These payments were implemented as part of various Agriculture Acts during this period (such as the 1957 Agriculture Act), with the aim of supporting farmers and stabilising agricultural incomes.
The fundamental concept behind deficiency payments is to compensate farmers for the difference between the target or guaranteed price set by the government and the market price for their agricultural produce. Market price may frequently fall below the guaranteed price following unusually good harvests, or because global supply has increased as a result of developing countries expanding production, and because new and more 'intensive' production methods increase global supply. Increases in global supply will suppress prices, and may even lead to countries 'dumping' their surpluses - adding to downward pressure on prices.
The diagram above shows the implementation of a deficiency payments scheme.
As can be seen, both the demand curve and the supply curve for this agricultural commodity are relatively steep indicating that, at least in the short run, both demand and supply are price inelastic. As a result of even small shifts in demand or supply, the market price P is likely to be volatile.
To help mitigate against this, a government may provide farmers with a guaranteed price of Pg.
At price Pg, farmers are willing and able to supply Q2 - much greater than consumer's are prepared consumer, at Q1.. To reduce or eliminate the excess supply at price Pg, consumers are charged the price that would encourage them to buy Q2 - namely, price P1.
The difference between what the government (or the governments appointed agency) will pay (Pg) and what consumers are charged (P1) is made up by the government’s deficiency payment per unit.
The impact of this intervention is:
This is because the increased price and quantity supplied will increase farmers’ total revenue. Furthermore, because the price is guaranteed, farmers no longer must worry about volatile price changes. This allows them to invest for the long term, boosting productivity and profits over time.
Consumers gain because price falls from P to P1 and quantity increases from Q to Q2. As a result, consumer surplus increases.
The shaded area in the diagram shows the cost to the taxpayer. In addition to the cost of the scheme itself, there will also be administrative costs involved in planning, organising and implementing the scheme.
This policy is provides an alternative to deficiency payments and targets quantity directly rather than price (as in the case of guaranteed prices). In the diagram below, a guaranteed price of Pg is still set by the government. If, at this price, supply exceeds demand (in this case, excess supply is equal to Q1 - Q2) the government will intervene by purchasing this excess and thereby preventing price from falling below the guarantee.
The impact of this intervention is that:
This is because both price and output increase leading to increased total revenue. Also, the price farmers or growers receive is guaranteed, providing them with guaranteed income for their output regardless of changes in supply and demand. This creates a more stable environment and is likely to encourage greater investment.
This is because price increases from P to Pg, resulting in a fall in consumer surplus.
Taxpayers lose because the government is committed to buying up the excess supply at price Pg. The cost of this intervention is equal to the shaded area in the above diagram. In addition to this cost, the excess produce must be distributed and stored appropriately. The storage of these items can be extremely expensive as often fresh produce needs to be refrigerated or frozen.
Intervention buying will, in all probability, generate surpluses. In the 1980s, the implementation of this policy in the UK and EU created vast surpluses of butter and milk, leading to the popular phrases: butter mountains and milk and wine lakes. The controversy heightened during the Band Aid era in the mid-1980s. Band Aid was a musical charity group formed to raise funds for famine relief in Ethiopia.
The stark contrast between the surplus food in the EU and the famine in Africa brought attention to the inefficiencies and moral implications of such an agricultural policy.
Buffer stock schemes involve governments setting what they see, as a ‘fair’ price for an agricultural commodity - such as price Pg in the diagram below. As with intervention buying, if the price falls below Pg the government will buy the excess supply of the commodity, boosting demand, and returning the price to Pg. However, buffer stocks also attempt to deal with poor harvests and shortages which could be the starting point for a period of price volatility. If the price rises above Pg as a result of a poor harvest, the government sells stocks of the commodity it has built up in the buffer stock to increase supply and lower the price back down to Pg.
In addition to deficiency payments, intervention buying and buffer stocks, governments may provide subsidies to farmers and growers in special circumstances.
For example, European farmers have received diesel and equipment subsidies to help reduce their production costs. However, a budget crisis in 2023 forced the German federal government to axe the fuel subsidies in addition to removing tax breaks for new agricultural equipment. (Source: The New European - 2024)