Optimality refers to the best outcome from a range of possible outcomes. Pareto optimality (named after Italian economist, Vilfredo Pareto) refers to a situation where an economy has arrived at an optimum point in terms of the efficient use of scarce resources.
Pareto optimality is arrived at when any change in the production and distribution of goods or services in order to make one group better off, makes someone worse off.
For example, consider a simple economy with just three individuals (X, Y and Z), consuming two products (A and B):
| X | Y | Z | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 200 | 400 | 60 |
| B | 100 | 300 | 40 |
The following scenario will not be optimal as it was possible to use and economy's scarce resources to increase how many units of good A and B are allocated to individual X (from 200 units to 250 units for A, and from 100 to 120 for B) without reducing the units of A and B available to individuals Y and Z.
| X | Y | Z | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 250 | 400 | 60 |
| B | 120 | 300 | 40 |
However, the following scenario will be optimal as it is not possible to reallocate scarce resources to increase units of good A and B going to X without reducing the units of A and B available to individuals Y (A falls from 400 to 375, and B from 300 to 295) and Z (A falls from 60 to 35, and B falls from 40 to 36).
| X | Y | Z | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 250 | 375 | 35 |
| B | 120 | 295 | 36 |
Pareto optimality is unlikely ever to be arrived at because new technologies are constantly being employed to enable increasing quantities of output from existing resources. As long as some labour (or other factors of production) remains unemployed, optimality will not be reached.
However, the concept of optimality is still valid in that it enables economists to assess the relative benefits of different economic decisions and policies.
For example, if a government could increase government spending on two types of good or services in a town (say a new hospital or new school) and spending on one (say the hospital) results in fewer people being make worse off than the same spending on other (the new school), then the decision to spend on the new hospital is more beneficial in terms of Pareto optimality.
In order to move an economy towards optimality various aspects of the economic system need to be efficient. The two fundamental types of efficiency are:
Efficiency in terms of production means that scarce resources are currently allocated towards the production of goods and services goods in such a way that it would not be possible to reallocate resources to increase the output of one good without reducing the output of another good.
Certain sectors of an economy may be productively inefficient, including agricultural production in developing economies - where it is possible to increase production of food without having to reduce the production of other goods and services.
For production to be efficient, two other types of efficiency must be present:
Technical efficiency means that, in order to produce a given amount of a good or service, the fewest scarce resources are used.
Cost efficiency means that units of output are produced at their lowest cost. In this case, lowest cost means lowest average cost (and not lowest total cost). To consider this further, go to costs of production.
Productive efficiency can be illustrated by using production possibility frontiers.
Efficiency in terms of exchange (called allocative efficiency) means that a bundle of goods and services cannot be reallocated between consumers without making one consumer worse off.
For example, if one household currently throws away 10% of their food as waste, and a system can be developed to redistribute this waste to other households, then the initial situation is sub-optimal, and the introduction of a redistribution system would be a step towards more optimal exchange efficiency.
One way to illustrate efficiency in exchange (allocative efficiency) is to consider the relationship between the prices of goods in the bundle, and the marginal cost of producing them.
The price consumers are prepared to pay for an additional (marginal) unit of a good or service is seen as a measure of expected benefit, or utility, and if this value equals the marginal cost of producing that unit of output, then the good or service is being allocated efficiently.
The condition for allocative efficiency is:
P = MC (for all goods and services produced)
Where P - price, and MC = marginal cost.
Allocative efficiency can be improved when resources are being used in a way that increases total utility to consumers.
It is likely that an increase in production efficiency will lead to an increase in exchange efficiency given that increased output may not need any reallocation between individuals to improve economic welfare.
Economists argue that production and exchange efficiency can vary between different economic systems (market, command and mixed) and with different types of competition between producers.
Go to dynamic efficiency