Electricity is a unique commodity and, unlike physical goods, cannot be stored in large quantities. This means that supply coming onto the market must continually match demand and a price must be arrived at which allows daily demand to match daily supply. Like many commodities, this is achieved through an auction process, where buyers bid for electricity and sellers offer electricity based on their marginal costs of production.
The UK is a member of the Nord Pool energy exchange, which involves some 16 European countries*.
The Nord Pool exchange sets the price according to the marginal cost of producing one more unit of electricity (a unit being a Megawatt of electricity).
Each trading day starts with customers placing their orders and suppliers making bids in terms of price order, from lowest to highest, until demand is met – the so-called ‘merit order’ system. Bids to join the power grid are based on the suppliers’ operating cost of production – their variable cost. The variable cost is the marginal cost, and includes fuel, labour and maintenance costs, and excludes fixed costs. The least costly entering first, and the most costly entering last. In effect, the marginal cost of the ‘final’ entrant into the market (the least efficient one) sets the market price for all other suppliers. Hence, all players in the wholesale market pay the same price. This is illustrated below:
Initially, the lowest cost suppliers (typically, renewables) bid first. Some renewable energy sources, such as wind, hydro and solar, are near-zero operating cost generators. When the wind blows or the sun shines, additional energy is almost free. Hence, renewables suppliers will be first to be selected to generate electricity. However, although renewables are the cheapest sources, they are unpredictable and unlikely to satisfy total market demand.
Higher cost suppliers then enter the market, with gas and coal powered electricity suppliers the last to enter given their much higher production costs, and also because they must also pay carbon tax on the fuel they use to generate electricity. While gas is one of the most expensive fuels in the generation of electricity, it is important in that it can be ‘turned on’ quickly when demand exceeds the capacity of lower cost suppliers. A significant increase in demand (to D1) – such as during an exceptionally cold winter – will result in gas being used from more expensive plants (Gas2), which drives up the price (to P1) - as shown below:
This means that, in order to satisfy demand, the last supplier to enter the market (the marginal supplier) needed to satisfy total market demand sets the price for the whole market.
In the Nord exchange, the price is set hourly so that supply can match demand throughout the day. In economic terms, the so-called merit order curve is the industry supply curve. Suppliers enter based on their marginal cost until demand is satisfied.
In this way, the market for electricity is structured to mirror how markets work in a free market economy, with the price being arrived at through the interaction of buyers and sellers. The fact that all suppliers receive the same price provides a benefit to the most efficient – lower-cost – suppliers. As their marginal cost is well below the marginal cost of the least efficient, the price (average revenue) can make an important contribution to investment and to profits.
The most efficient generators will meet the demand while those who are the most expensive may be ‘out of merit’ and will not sell at all.
It is easy to see the marginal impact of a rise in gas prices - for example, the rise following the Russia-Ukraine conflict. When demand is high, or at its maximum, any increase in gas prices will have a direct and significant impact on the marginal cost of electricity in the wholesale market.
It is clear that energy security will be improved by investing more in renewables and nuclear production, which will mean that more of the market is satisfied by low cost domestic electricity, with less reliance on gas - which is likely to be imported. Investing in more renewables and nuclear power would also have the benefit of reducing marginal costs, and lowering prices.
*Nord Pool is appointed as a Nominated Electricity Market Operator (NEMO) in Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Great Britain, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Poland and Sweden