Competition policy
Competition policy is designed to correct problems that arise when firms behave in an anti-competitive manner as a result of the
abuse of monopoly power.
Market power can arise when markets are controlled by a single firm (a
pure monopolist) or by a few firms (an
oligopoly).
Abuse of market power is seen as a market failure because the interplay
of free market forces does not eliminate the possibility that firms may
abuse their power.
Types of market abuse
Firms can abuse their power in several ways, including:
- Limiting output to the market to artificially create a
shortage leading
to 'inflated' prices.
- Setting price higher than would occur if the market operated in a
competitive way.
- Setting price lower than the free-market price to drive competitors out of
business.
- Taking over or merging with another firm in the same market
to
reduce competition (horizontal integration)
- see JD Sports example
- Taking over or merging with another firm in the supply chain
to control either supplies or outlets (vertical integration)
- Putting up other barriers to entry to reduce potential competition.
- Colluding with other firms to rig the market in favour of the producer.
Regulators
The role of competition regulators is to ensure that firms do not abuse
their market power and create a level playing field for existing firms and
new entrants into a market.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)
In the UK, the CMA has the task of implementing competition policy, as laid
down in various competition laws.
Role of the CMA
The CMA has five key roles. To:
- Investigate mergers between organisations, to ensure that competition is
not reduced.
- Investigate whole markets when problems are identified.
- Take action against businesses and individuals that take part in cartels or anti-competitive behaviour,
including levying fines of up to 10% of turnover.
- Protect consumers from unfair trading practices.
- Encourage government and other regulators to use competition effectively on behalf of consumers.
The CMA and abuse of market power
The CMA and price fixing
Following a merger the CMA can force a demerger, as in the case of the merger
between
JD Sports and Footasylum (who
merged in 2019 but were instructed to reverse the merger in 2021). The view of
the CMA is that choice would be greatly reduced, with a strong likelihood of higher prices, fewer discounts, and less choice in-store.
The digital economy
In April 2021, a new Digital Markets Unit (DMU) was set up within the CMA
to monitor and regulate the behaviour of platforms with significant market power,
including Facebook and Google. This follows concerns about the spread of 'fake
news', possible interference with elections and platforms favouring goods and
services which they own or control.