Problems facing policy makers

Governments face specific problems when selecting and implementing policies to influence the macroeconomy.

Inaccurate information

Governments may face the Hayekian knowledge problem – the idea that governments can never know as much as consumers, producers and the markets they operate in, nor can they obtain information at the time when it is most useful. While forecasting has become more sophisticated and more accurate, it is clear that economic systems are highly complex and it is also doubtful that policies will inevitably work.

Inability to deal with external shocks

While economic shocks originating within a macroeconomy are challenging for policymakers, those originating abroad are especially challenging and destabilising for ‘open’ economies, such as the UK.

External shocks are those originating outside the domestic macroeconomic system, and include the impact of wars, financial crashes, and pandemics which create ripples across the global economy and may push domestic policy to its limits. Of course, while policies can mitigate against some of these external shocks, domestic budgets may be limited so that fiscal policy is constrained, and supply-side policy is too slow to have any effect on sudden shocks.

The importance of flexibility

Dealing with external shocks effectively requires having a set of policies which allow the macroeconomy to adjust quickly. Why external shocks cannot be prevented, their impact can be reduced.

While economists disagree about the precise mix of policies, possible ways to increase flexibility include:

  1. The use of automatic stabilisers in the tax and welfare system, which means having greater progressiveness which will moderate the unstable effects of external shocks.
  2. A flexible exchange rate, which means that a currency can rise of fall in the face of external events, and which provides a countercyclical effect – for example, a sudden collapse in the fortunes of a trading partner of the UK, which would normally have seen a fall in exports from the UK, would lead to a fall in the value of Sterling, which in turn could trigger an increase in demand for exports from the trading partner.
  3. A flexible labour market would also increase an economy’s ability to deal with shocks. In the event of a negative shock, UK firms could cut back on demand for labour by reducing hours and possibly placing workers on a part-time contract. In contrast, countries with inflexible labour markets, such as in Spain, Italy, Greece and Portugal tend to suffer most following external shocks. In Greece in particular, the public sector was ‘ring-fenced’ and the Greek government found it difficult to reduce its size, and as a result built up unsustainable public debt. This is not to say that workers’ rights should be abandoned in the search for increased flexibility, but that a highly rigid labour market will tend to amplify the negative effects of any external shock.
  4. A dynamic financial sector which is capable of reacting to shocks and ensuring there is enough liquidity in the system is also recognised as being essential to any economy in withstanding external shocks.