Member Hub
Member Hub
Study Hub ›

Production possibility diagrams

A production possibility diagram - also called frontier, curve or boundary - shows the possible combinations of two goods (or services) that can be produced using all an economy’s resources.

Here we will used the term production possibility frontier (PPF). PPFs are used to explain several economic concepts, including efficiency, choice and opportunity cost.

Opportunity cost

Opportunity cost refers to the cost of a given decision expressed in terms of the sacrifice made - more formally, opportunity cost can be quantified in terms of the next best alternative forgone.

Figures for possible combinations can be shown in a PPF schedule, as shown below:

Production possibility frontiers

The combinations can be shown through a PPF, as show:

Taking this example, increasing a given quantity of capital goods, from X0 to X1, leads to a small loss of consumer goods, Y12 to Y11 - hence the opportunity cost is ‘1Y’. Increasing X by a further given amount, X1 to X2, leads to a loss of 2 units of Y -Y11 to Y9 - with an opportunity cost of ‘2Y’, and the economy moves from point 'a' to point 'b'

Production possibility frontiers

Increasing capital goods from X2 to X3 creates an opportunity cost of ‘3Y’, and finally increasing capital goods to X4 creates an opportunity cost of ‘6Y’.

The opportunity cost of a decision to increase the production of X is expressed in terms of the loss of Y, and increases as more goods are produced.

Video on PPFs

PPFs and efficiency

Production possibilities frontiers (PPFs) can be used to illustrate the idea of productive efficiency.

Productive efficiency relates to how scarce resources are used to create goods and services.

There are two ways to analyse productive efficiency - firstly, if the economy is productively efficient then all units of goods and services are being produced at their lowest average cost.

Secondly, we could consider how many units of output are being created from a given quantity of an input. For example, we could assess productive efficiency by considering labour productivity - namely, output per worker.

Efficiency and preferences

While all points on a PPF are equally efficient, given that the combinations represent the maximum production possible by using all an economy's scarce resources, they are not all equally desirable.

For example, point ‘b’ may be preferred to point ‘c’ as it contains more consumer goods, leading to a higher current standard of living.

PPFs and efficiency

However, it could be argued that point ‘c’ may be preferable in that, with more capital goods produced in the short run, the economy can grow and eventually produce more consumer goods in the long run, at point ‘x’. The PPF shifts outwards as a result of increased capital spending.


Pareto efficiency

Pareto efficiency can be understood by using PPFs. A point on a PPF is referred to as 'Pareto efficient' given that, when on the boundary, the only way to increase the output of one good is to decrease the output of the other good. If this condition is not met, then an economy is operating below Pareto efficiency and can, therefore, increase output without reducing output elsewhere in the economy.

Pareto efficiency was named after Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto. As well as considering efficiency by using a PPF, it can also be understood by considering what happens when an economy is efficient and inefficient. If it is possible to make one individual better off - by using resources more efficiently - and not make anyone worst off, then Pareto efficiency has NOT been reached.

It is only when resources have to be transferred from one individual to another to make that individual better off that maximum efficiency has been reached - this equates to operating on the edge or boundary of the existing PPF.

PPFs and unemployment

Production possibility frontiers (PPFs) - which show all the possible combinations of two goods an economy can produce from its resources - can be used to illustrate unemployment in an economy.

PPFs

All points on a PPF, including 'a', 'b' and 'c' in the diagram below are equally efficient and attainable given that they use all the available scarce recourses. However, point ‘d’ is not currently attainable as it lies outside the existing PPF.  Though point 'd' is unattainable it may be an objective for the future.

In contrast, point ‘e’ is attainable, but inefficient as more could be produced of both goods. It is possible to have X2, and 3 more units of Y (at Y9), and to have Y6, and 1 more of X (at X3).

PPFs and unemployment

Point 'e' also illustrates the idea of Pareto efficiency, as more of X and Y can be achieved without any sacrifice. Hence, point ‘e’ both inefficient and implies that there are unemployed resources in the economy.

PPFs can be used to illustrated the under-utilisation of capital as well as unemployment of labour. Point 'e' also equates to the idea of a negative output gap.

While PPFs are useful in terms of illustrating the idea of unemployment, they do not help distinguish the cause of unemployment. The diagram does not indicate whether unemployment is caused by a lack of demand (demand deficient unemployment) or from structural factors in the economy.

Movements in the position of point 'e' can also illustrate whether the level of unemployment is changing

Read more on unemployment.

Video on PPFs and unemployment

Non-linear production possibility frontiers

A production possibility frontier, or PPF, (also called a production possibility curve or boundary) shows the possible combinations of two goods that can be produced using all an economy’s resources. 

What are PPFs non-linear?

In the example, increasing a given quantity of Sector B goods, X0 to X1, leads to a small loss of Sector A goods, Y12 to Y11 - the opportunity cost is ‘1Y’.

Increasing X by a further given amount, X1 to X2, leads to a loss of 2 units of Y -Y11 to Y9 - with an opportunity cost of ‘2Y’.

Increasing Sector B goods from X2 to X3 creates an opportunity cost of ‘3Y’, and finally increasing Sector B goods to X4 creates an opportunity cost of ‘6Y’. Opportunity cost increases as more goods are produced.

The law of diminishing returns

There are several ways to explain why opportunity cost increases, but perhaps the most useful starting point is to consider the 'law of diminishing marginal returns'.

Assuming only two goods or sectors, as more of one is produced (say, in Sector B) - resources must be transferred from the other sector. At first, those factors best suited to being transferred, (including labour) leave the sector.

The effect of this is that the gain to Sector B from the transferred resource is much greater than the loss to Sector A from losing the resource.

However, as Sector B continues to expand, less suitable workers (and other factors) must eventually be transferred - hence, the gains from transferring diminish, and hence the opportunity cost gradually increases.

Video on PPFs

The principle is also referred to as the diminishing marginal rate of transformation.