Member Hub
Member Hub
Study Hub ›

The national debt

Distinction between a budget deficit and the national debt

A budget deficit is the deficit that the public sector accrues during one financial year as a result of current and capital expenditure being greater than revenue from all sources.

A budget surplus arises when annual revenue is greater than expenditure.

A country’s national debt is the cumulative amount of debt that a country owes to national creditors.

Fiscal deficits will add to the national debt and fiscal surpluses will reduce the national debt.

Distinction between structural and cyclical deficits

Public finances will change over the business cycle, with finances moving toward a deficit when the economy is slowing down or going into recession, and moving towards a surplus when the economy grows.

Automatic stabilizers moderate the upward and downward effect of the business cycle.

Cyclical deficits

A cyclical deficit is likely to occur in the downturn and recession phase of the business cycle. In this phase, tax receipts from income (from direct and indirect tax) start to decline, while expenditure on welfare transfers and benefits start to rise.

As a fiscal boost starts to work, the economy will return to growth, and tax receipts again start to rise and government expenditures start to fall – at least this is the simple theory of cyclical deficits and surpluses.

Over time they should start to even out.

However, it is possible (and more likely for many economies) that a cyclical balance is not achieved.

Structural deficits

When an economy has a permanent fiscal deficit it is said to have a structural deficit. The ‘structural’ deficit is an assessment of how large the deficit would be if the economy was operating at a 'normal', level of employment and activity. What is 'normal' cannot be precisely measured, but various statistical techniques can be used to make an assessment.

A structural deficit is significantly worse than a cyclical deficit in that there is a permanent gap between revenue and spending when the economy is in its 'normal' state.

This can be dealt with by trying to change the fundamental structure of public finances, including cutting back on public spending or on increasing existing taxes, or from introducing new taxes. Of course, relying on borrowing is possible if repayments are sustainable.

Each of these has risks attached:

Permanently cutting back on spending has political and economic risks in that it is possible that cutting back on spending creates a period of austerity, falling standards of living, rising inequality and poverty, and austerity leads to falling tax revenues in the future which could worsen public finances.

Increasing taxes can create a disincentive effect of work and effort, and result in FDI being switched to another country. It may also create an environment where tax avoidance is seen as a rational option, and, in some developing countries, may increase the size of the hidden economy – thereby leading to a reduction in tax revenues in the future – a significant unintended consequence of the policy.

The final option is to borrow more, but there are significant risks associated with this, including the loss of creditworthiness if borrowing becomes significant.

A country’s credit rating may be downgraded, with increases in the cost of borrowing further down the line.

Borrowing is also potentially inflationary if borrowing is from the money markets, because issuing government debt through treasury bills is potentially adding to the money supply.

Of course, borrowing will need to be paid back, which can create an increased tax burden on future generations.

Factors influencing the size of fiscal deficits

Fiscal deficits are influenced by several factors, including:

  1. The 'position' of the economy in its business cycle - in other words, the growth rate in the economy.
  2. Tax rates, including marginal tax rates - higher marginal tax rates will act as a shock absorber against excessive economic growth, and welfare benefits will prevent recessions becoming too deep and prolonged.
  3. Government spending plans, including specific spending projects such as infrastructure improvements.
  4. The extent of tax evasion and tax avoidance.
  5. Tax loopholes may mean a loss of potential tax revenue.
  6. Capital flight, with a loss of beneficial investment resources causes a potential loss of revenue from capital gains.
  7. Interest payments accruing from national debts.

Factors influencing the size of national debts

Many of the factors that contribute to deficits clearly contribute to cumulative deficits and hence the national debt.

In addition to those factors are:

  1. Low savings ratios, which mean that tax revenues are relatively small.
  2. The structure of the population can also affect debt – for example, a high birth and a low death rate puts pressure on healthcare services for an extended period of time, with tax revenues insufficient to pay for these services.
  3. The level of development of the country – countries with low development levels may not be able to collect enough tax revenue to spend on projects that will improve development in the future, such as spending on infrastructure projects. This may force them into borrowing, which raises debt levels.
  4. The cost of servicing debt – many developing countries have a considerable debt and hence cost of serving that debt (the debt interest) can add further to the debt. Unless debts are rescheduled or written off, the national debt for many countries will simply continue to rise. The effect of any national disasters or military conflicts - some of which may be supported through aid, but some may be supported by borrowing.

The significance of the size of fiscal deficits and national debts

The significance of the size of deficits and the national debt is best understood in by looking at them a proportion of GDP. For example, if GDP is rising by 5% in money or nominal terms, and the fiscal deficit or national debt is rising by 7% in money or nominal terms, then the 'real' burden of the deficit or debt is rising. Conversely, if nominal GDP rises by 5% and nominal debt is rising by 2%, then real debt is falling. Given that deficits add to the national debt, the effects of deficits and debts are potentially the same.

A large real debt burden can have the following effects:

  1. It creates a burden for future generations, which means that they may have to cope with higher tax payments or fewer public services.
  2. Debt can be inflationary if it is funded by borrowing from the money markets. If government debt is funded by selling debt to the banks, it adds to the money supply. This is because short term debt is sold through Treasury Bills which the banks can consider as highly liquid and 'near to cash'. So for every unit of currency sold to the banks there is one more unit it of currency in the money supply.
  3. Rising debt can increase financial and resource crowding out, which raises long term interest rates and stifled the private sector.
  4. The 'pain' of policy which attempts to reduce debt burdens, including the 'austerity economics' of public sector cutbacks and tight fiscal controls.