Manchesterism
Manchesterism is a modern approach to economic policy which argues that markets work best when they are supported by effective government, strong local decision-making and investment in public services. Associated with newly appointed Prime Minister Andy Burnham, it combines elements of Keynesian economics, supply-side policy and regional devolution.
Modern Manchesterism
Modern Manchesterism is a political and economic approach developed largely from Burnham's experience of governing Greater Manchester. It seeks to combine economic growth with greater social justice through an active state, stronger regional government and cooperation between the public and private sectors.
The term has an interesting history. During the nineteenth century, Manchesterism referred to the ideas of the Manchester School, associated particularly with Richard Cobden and John Bright. This earlier version promoted free trade, private enterprise and limited government intervention.
Modern Manchesterism uses the same name for a substantially different economic approach. It argues that government should help to shape markets, invest in infrastructure and skills, devolve economic power and ensure that essential services operate in the public interest. Burnham's version has consequently been described as a form of business-friendly socialism.
Manchesterism does not reject private enterprise or the market economy. Instead, it proposes a partnership in which businesses create investment, employment and innovation, while government provides infrastructure, corrects market failures and pursues wider economic and social objectives that the price mechanism largely ignores.
It is best understood as a process rather than a guaranteed outcome. Manchesterism describes a way of governing and making economic decisions. Its eventual effects on growth, productivity, inequality and living standards will depend on the policies adopted and how successfully they are implemented. At least in terms of growth, as Mr. Burnham correctly points out, Manchester has become the UK's hothouse of growth when compared with other UK cities.
- Devolution: transferring economic powers and financial responsibility from Westminster to cities and regions.
- An active state: using public investment and targeted intervention to support growth and improve living standards.
- Public control of essential services: including possible public ownership of natural monopoly utilities.
- Market-friendly intervention: working with private businesses rather than attempting to replace the market economy.
- Inclusive growth: seeking to spread employment, investment and prosperity more evenly between regions and social groups.
The three defining features of Manchesterism
1. Greater devolution of economic decision-making
One of the central principles of Manchesterism is that local leaders may understand local economic conditions better than central government in Westminster. Devolution would allow Cities, combined authorities and regions to receive greater control over areas such as transport, housing, planning, adult education, skills and economic development.
The economic argument is that local decision-makers possess more detailed information about local labour markets, infrastructure shortages and business needs. Devolution could be said to partly resolve the 'knowledge problem' closely associated with central government and its failure to understand and support the market economy. Devolution could therefore produce policies that are better targeted and improve the allocation of public resources at the local level.
Greater local control could also allow different regions to experiment with different policies. Successful approaches could then be copied elsewhere. However, devolution would need to be accompanied by sufficient funding and clear accountability if it is to produce meaningful economic change.
2. An active state working with markets
Manchesterism does not argue that government should replace markets or private enterprise. Instead, it supports an active state that works with businesses, local authorities and other organisations to achieve economic objectives.
This approach contains elements of Keynesian economics. During periods of weak demand, government investment may support employment and economic activity. Investment in transport, housing and public services can create a direct increase in aggregate demand, with further increases occurring through the multiplier effect.
It also contains a supply-side element. Investment in infrastructure, education, training and health may increase labour productivity, improve occupational mobility and encourage private-sector investment. If these policies are successful, they could increase the productive capacity of the economy and shift long-run aggregate supply to the right.
3. Public control of essential services and natural monopolies
Manchesterism places particular importance on essential services such as water, energy networks, and transport such as railways and local bus services. These industries may contain elements of natural monopoly, where very high fixed costs and substantial economies of scale make it inefficient to duplicate the infrastructure required to provide the service.
For example, it would be extremely costly and disruptive for several competing water companies to construct separate networks of pipes to every home. A single supplier may therefore be able to provide the service at a lower average cost than several competing firms.
However, a private natural monopoly may restrict output, charge high prices or underinvest in infrastructure in order to increase profit - a criticism leveled at many of the UK's privatised water companies. Manchesterism therefore allows for tighter regulation, municipal ownership or nationalisation where public control is considered more likely to protect consumers and secure long-term investment.
Of course, nationalisation does not automatically produce economic efficiency, let alone maximise it. Publicly owned organisations would still require clear objectives, effective management, investment plans and systems of accountability. The economic case rests on whether public ownership produces better outcomes than private ownership and regulation, and whether it can be financed at a time of growing fiscal debt.
Manchesterism and market failure
A central justification for Manchesterism is that free markets do not always allocate resources in a socially efficient way. Government intervention may therefore be used to correct market failure, including:
- Public transport: subsidised and integrated transport networks may reduce congestion, air pollution and carbon emissions, while improving access to employment.
- Education and training: government-funded skills programmes may generate positive externalities and help to correct occupational immobility in the labour market.
- Affordable housing: public and social housebuilding may address housing shortages, improve geographical mobility and reduce overcrowding.
- Environmental policy: regulation, investment and taxation may be used to reduce negative externalities associated with pollution and greenhouse-gas emissions.
- Natural monopolies: public ownership or stronger regulation may prevent monopoly power from producing excessive prices, poor service or insufficient investment.
Manchesterism therefore treats government intervention as a possible means of improving market outcomes rather than as an objective in itself. The relevant economic test is whether the intervention produces a larger increase in social welfare than its opportunity cost.
Manchesterism compared with a free-market approach
| Traditional free-market approach | Modern Manchesterism |
|---|---|
| A relatively limited economic role for government | An active but targeted role for government |
| Central government retains most economic powers | Greater devolution to cities, regions and local authorities |
| Privatisation and private ownership are generally preferred | Public ownership or stronger public control may be preferred for natural monopolies and essential services |
| Competition is the main mechanism for improving efficiency | Competition is supported, but government intervenes when markets fail |
| Lower taxation and public spending may encourage enterprise | Strategic public investment may increase productivity and stimulate private investment |
| Market outcomes largely determine the regional distribution of economic activity | Regional policy is used to spread growth and opportunity more evenly |
The possible economic benefits of Manchesterism
1. More effective correction of market failure
Public investment and targeted intervention may improve the allocation of resources where unregulated markets produce socially inefficient outcomes.
For example, an improved public transport network may reduce congestion and pollution while increasing labour mobility. Investment in education and training may generate positive externalities because the wider economy benefits from a more productive workforce. Affordable housing programmes could also make it easier for workers to live near employment opportunities.
From a microeconomic perspective, these policies may move output closer to the socially efficient level and increase economic welfare.
2. Higher productivity and long-run economic growth
Investment in transport, digital infrastructure, housing, health and skills may increase the quality and productivity of factors of production.
Better transport can reduce journey times and business costs. Improved education and training can increase human capital. Better health services may reduce economic inactivity and absenteeism. These effects could lower firms' costs and encourage private investment.
From a macroeconomic perspective, successful supply-side improvements may shift long-run aggregate supply to the right, increasing potential output and allowing the economy to grow with less inflationary pressure.
3. Reduced regional inequality
Greater devolution could allow economic policies to reflect the particular needs of different cities and regions. Areas experiencing industrial decline, low investment or poor transport links may require different policies from economically stronger regions.
If Manchesterism attracts investment and creates higher-productivity employment outside London and the South East, it could reduce regional differences in income, employment and living standards.
More balanced regional growth may also reduce pressure on housing and infrastructure in already congested parts of the country.
4. Better outcomes from essential utilities
Nationalisation, municipal ownership or stronger regulation of natural monopoly utilities could allow prices, investment and service standards to be determined with greater regard for the public interest.
Public control may make it possible to adopt longer investment horizons, retain surpluses for infrastructure improvements and pursue environmental or social objectives that a profit-maximising firm might not prioritise.
Consumers could benefit from lower prices or improved reliability if public management is efficient. Businesses may also gain from better infrastructure and greater certainty over future provision.
The possible economic costs of Manchesterism
1. Higher government spending, taxation or borrowing
Major investment in infrastructure, housing and public services requires substantial financial resources. The government may need to finance this through higher taxation, additional borrowing or reductions in spending elsewhere.
Higher taxes may reduce household disposable income or weaken incentives to work, save and invest. Additional borrowing may increase public debt and debt-interest payments, creating an opportunity cost because less money is available for other government priorities.
The long-run fiscal effect depends partly on the return generated by the investment. Projects that raise productivity, employment and tax revenue may partly or fully pay for themselves over time. Poorly selected projects may leave taxpayers with higher debt but few lasting economic benefits.
2. Government failure
Market failure does not guarantee that intervention will improve economic welfare. Governments may lack accurate information (the 'knowledge problem'), respond to political pressures, or allocate resources inefficiently.
Large infrastructure projects may exceed their budgets, experience long delays or produce lower benefits than originally forecast. Devolved authorities may also vary in their administrative abilities and quality of leadership.
Intervention could therefore create government failure if its economic and social costs exceed the welfare loss caused by the original market failure.
3. Weaker incentives and productive inefficiency
Publicly owned organisations may face less competitive pressure to minimise costs, innovate or respond quickly to consumers. Managers may also have weaker incentives to improve performance if losses are covered by the government.
This could lead to productive inefficiency, overstaffing or poor-quality services. Political objectives might also influence pricing and investment decisions, even where these decisions are not economically efficient.
These risks could be reduced through independent management, transparent performance targets and external scrutiny, but they cannot necessarily be removed entirely.
4. Uncertainty and crowding out of private investment
The prospect of tighter regulation, higher business taxation or future nationalisation may create uncertainty for private investors. Firms may postpone or cancel investment if they are unsure about future ownership, regulation or expected profitability.
Government borrowing may also contribute to financial crowding out if it raises interest rates and makes private-sector borrowing more expensive, although this effect is likely to depend on the condition of the economy and the response of monetary policy.
On the other hand, public investment may crowd in private investment when improved infrastructure and skills increase the expected profitability of private-sector projects. The overall effect cannot therefore be assumed in advance.
Conclusion
Manchesterism is perhaps best viewed as an attempt to establish a middle ground between a largely free-market economy and extensive state control of resources. It accepts that markets and private enterprise are important sources of innovation, investment and employment, and that information moves freely between consumers and producers leading to an efficient allocation of resources in those areas where market are most successful - namely, private goods. However, it also argues that private markets require effective public institutions, modern infrastructure and intervention where significant market failures exist.
Its success is likely to depend less on the total amount of government intervention than on its quality. Devolving decisions could improve policy by making it more responsive to local conditions, but only if regional authorities possess sufficient funding, expertise and accountability. Similarly, nationalisation could improve the performance of natural monopolies, but only if public ownership is accompanied by effective management and incentives to control costs.
The effects of Manchesterism will also depend on the wider state of the economy. Public investment may be particularly valuable when demand is weak, unemployment is high and borrowing can finance projects with strong long-term returns. The same programme may be more difficult to justify when the economy is close to full capacity, inflation is high or public finances are severely constrained.
Ultimately, Manchesterism will be judged not by how much government intervenes, but by whether that intervention improves economic efficiency and living standards more effectively than the market acting alone.
Finally, critics argue that a significant proportion of Greater Manchester's recent economic success may have occurred even without Manchesterism. Many of the city's competitive advantages were already firmly established before Andy Burnham became Mayor in 2017. For example, the regeneration of Salford Quays, which began during the 1980s and accelerated with the opening of MediaCityUK in 2011, had already transformed the area into one of Europe's leading media and digital clusters, attracting organisations such as the BBC, ITV and hundreds of technology businesses.
Likewise, substantial Middle Eastern investment associated with the acquisition of Manchester City Football Club by the Abu Dhabi United Group in 2008 helped stimulate wider regeneration around the Etihad Campus and attracted significant commercial and property investment into East Manchester. Although this continued during Burnham's period as Mayor, much of the investment reflected long-term commercial decisions rather than the direct result of Manchesterism.
A further example is Airport City Manchester, a £1 billion development launched before Burnham became Mayor. The development has attracted major employers such as Amazon, DHL and THG, creating thousands of jobs and strengthening Manchester's position as an international logistics and business hub.
More generally, Manchester's large student population, internationally recognised universities, excellent transport links, expanding airport, and growing digital and knowledge sector may themselves have attracted considerable inward investment. From this perspective, Manchesterism may therefore have acted more as a catalyst rather than a creator of economic growth.
Sources
- Reuters – What is Andy Burnham's Manchesterism vision for the UK?
- The Guardian – Good growth in every postcode: Burnham's economic priorities
- Associated Press – The challenges facing Andy Burnham as Prime Minister
- LabourList – Manchesterism, Manchester and Andy Burnham
- Encyclopaedia Britannica – The Manchester School
- Salford City Council
- Manchester City Council