Answering exam questions
Using chains of reasoning - example 2
To achieve high marks in longer examination questions students should use a
logical chain of reasoning.
This will help the examiner understand the thinking behind an answer, and demonstrates a logical approach.
Using a logical chain of reasoning helps improve an answer and takes it to the highest assessment level.
It also helps identify missing
elements, and helps avoid jumping to a point or
assertion without showing how this was arrived at.
Here, we consider an example of chains of reasoning - while these have
nine steps in the chain, a chain could have more or less than nine, depending on the question.
Example two - a weakening exchange rate
Question
To what extent does the weakening of a country's exchange rate help it
achieve its macroeconomic policy objectives?
Chain of reasoning - steps
- The exchange rate of a country is the value of its currency in terms of other currencies. They can be expressed as bi-lateral rates (e.g. $1 = £0.8) or as an exchange rate index.
This is usually based on a trade weighted index derived from measuring the
movement of one currency against a basked of other key currencies.
- Weakening means that a national currency will buy less foreign currency,
which can affect all the key macroeconomic objectives, including growth,
stable prices, jobs and trade.
- A weaker exchange rate may stimulate exports (which are an injection into the circular flow), and contribute to AD. If so, this is likely to shift AD to the right. (Draw an AD-AS diagram, with shift).
- This may be beneficial in terms of achieving growth - though it depends on the elasticity of aggregate supply. (Annotate graph with a new
level of GDP/Y on the x-axis).
- Jobs are a function of output, so it is likely that - with a time lag - jobs are created and unemployment may fall.
- However, there is upward pressure on the price level from two sources: as a result of the shift in AD causing demand-pull inflation (show on graph), and,
- From upward pressure on costs, through cost-push inflation resulting from more expensive imports.
- Finally, the effect on the current account balance is uncertain - if the Marshall-Lerner condition is satisfied, then a lower valued currency will improve the current account, but possibly not in the short run (illustrate with J-curve).
- In conclusion, it is not clear that a weaker currency will have a net-beneficial effect - while jobs and growth may be the short term effect, inflation in the longer term, and current account problems may
erode any benefits. A falling exchange rate can also have damaging effects on
confidence and expectations. For these reasons, exchange rate stability is usually seen as most desirable.
Go to an example of chains of reasoning - the
impact of a sugar tax.