facebook instagram youtube x

Voluntary and involuntary unemployment

One way to classify unemployment is to distinguish between voluntary and involuntary unemployment.

Voluntary unemployment

Voluntary unemployment refers to a situation where workers are able to work at the going real market wage rate but choose not to, perhaps just for a short period of time. [1]

This definition can be developed to include the concept of marginal productivity, as did Keynes [2] when he identified voluntary unemployment as a situation when a worker is unwilling to accept a reward that is equivalent to value of the marginal product they create. In other words, while pay reflects the value of marginal productivity, the worker - for whatever reason - does not want to accept that work.

Hence, frictional unemployment - where individuals are changing jobs or delaying taking a new job for a short period of time - is usually placed into the voluntary category of unemployment.

Involuntary unemployment

Involuntary unemployment is a situation where workers are willing and able to work at the going real market wage rate, but they cannot find work. This is a result of cyclical unemployment caused by a downturn in the economic cycle.

During the downturn, workers leave the market, perhaps temporarily, as firms downsize or dissolve, and may re-join the labour market when the economy begins to grow - perhaps with a considerable time lag between changes in aggregate demand and the labour market.

Dual labour market theory

One way to explain voluntary unemployment is to distinguish between the primary and secondary labour market.

The primary labour market

The primary labour market generally involves permanent-type jobs, with nationally negotiated pay rates, with larger enterprises and organisations as the major employers, and where jobs tend to be full-time.

Workers tend to become attached to this market and look for long-term employment with a career ladder and promotional prospects. Pay in the primary labour market is relatively high, with jobs well designed, and where workers may be offered considerable training.

The secondary labour market

The secondary labour market is exactly the opposite, and involves temporary-type jobs, with locally set pay rates, with variable hours of work, and with small enterprises as the major employers. Workers are not attached to this market or to the firms that they temporarily work for, and often look for short-term employment without a career ladder or promotional prospects. Jobs in the secondary labour market tend to be lower paid and less well designed, with little training.

Dual markets and unemployment

The idea of a dual labour market is appealing because it can help clarify the difference between voluntary and involuntary unemployment.

Workers in the primary labour market are likely to be more 'choosy' in terms of what work they accept, and may prefer to remain jobless for a period of time if they leave one job (say because they realise that there are no promotional opportunities) in favour of one that does. They are prepared to wait a while to find a job that appeals to them. Workers in the primary labour market are more likely to be able to rely on savings while unemployed. Of course, involuntary unemployment is still likely in the primary sector, as a downturn or recession may cause job losses across the economy.

In the secondary labour market, employment is more fluid, and it is less likely that workers will be so 'choosy' in terms of what work they accept.

While there may still be voluntary unemployment in the secondary labour market, workers are more likely to accept lower pay, and remain voluntarily unemployed for just a short period of time.

[1] Andrew Dunn, blog - Senior Lecturer in Social Policy at the University of Lincoln

[2] John Maynard Keynes, in The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money (1936),