facebook instagram youtube x

Exchange rates

An exchange rate is the price at which one currency exchanges for another one.

Bi-lateral rates are the specific value of one currency in terms of another – such as 1 US dollar exchanging for 1.10 euros. ‘Average’ rates can be tracked by the use of an index, such as the U.S. dollar index (USDX), or the Sterling Trade-Weighted Index.

These track currency values against a basket of other currencies. Changes are ‘weighted’ to reflect the relative importance of different currencies in terms of trade.

Rate determination

How rates are determined depends upon the system (or 'regime') used.

There are three basic exchange rate regimes:

  1. Fixed rates - where the rate of one currency is pegged to another currency or precious metal
  2. Floating rates - where rates are determined in the Foreign Exchange market, and vary according to the relative demand and supply of currency
  3. Hybrid systems - which combine elements of fixed and floating systems

Floating rates

In a freely floating system rates are determined by the forces of demand and supply operating in the foreign exchange market. The demand and supply of currencies originates from the need to pay for international transactions in local currencies.

When consumers, firms, or governments in one country buy another country’s products or invest in their assets they must exchange their currencies. The demand and supply of currencies ultimately comes from trade and investment flows.

For example, rates are pushed up when demand for a country's currency increases as its exports or investment opportunities become more popular abroad. Rates are pushed down when the reverse happens, and more is imported from abroad, or the country invests more in other countries.

Exchange rates are also affected by changes in relative interest rates, inflation rates, speculation and confidence levels also affect currency values.

Changes in market rates

The diagram below shows that an equilibrium exchange rate exists when the demand for and supply of a currency equal each other. The diagram relates to the equilibrium rate between the US dollar and the European euro.

At this equilibrium rate, the foreign exchange market clears. At the equilibrium rate, the simple model of exchange rate determination suggests that the value of import spending and export revenue will balance.

Any changes to the value of imports or exports will shift the supply or demand for a currency - an increase in imports shifts the supply to the right, and an increase in exports shifts the demand to the right.


Exchange rate diagram

If we assume the starting equilibrium is at a (where $1 = €1.10) an increase in exports will push demand for the currency to the right, with the equilibrium moving to e1, with the exchange rate increasing to $1 = €1.15). However, and increase in imports will shift the supply of dollars to S1, causing downward pressure on the exchange rate.

Video on exchange rates

Benefits of floating rates

An important benefit of floating rates is that the current account of the balance of payments will move back towards equilibrium following a change in trade flows. This is because changes in imports and exports in one time period alter the exchange rate, which means that trade flows adjust in the future.

For example, assume the exchange rate between the US dollar and UK pound is in equilibrium at £1=$1.40, and that the quantity of pounds traded is £50bn. We can also assume that the current account is in balance, with the UK's imports and exports equalling £50bn (assuming imports and exports are the only elements of the balance of payments).

If there is now an increase in imports from the US, the supply of pounds will increase (to S1) - given that UK traders must sell pounds to buy US dollars. The effect if to create a trade deficit of £20bn (with imports at £60bn, and exports at £40bn).

Welfare at equilibrium and non-equilibrium

The effect of this is to push the value of the pound down to £1-$1.20, causing exports to increase to £50bn, and imports to fall to £50bn, re-establishing a current account balance.

Fixed rates

In contrast, a fixed system involves currencies being pegged by a country’s central bank, or through a ‘currency board’ – as in the case of the Hong Kong currency board which pegs the Hong Kong dollar to the US dollar. Under the post-war IMF system currencies had a fixed value against the US dollar, which itself was pegged to gold, but this collapsed in 1971, leaving national currencies to float freely, or be pegged, or even abandoned as countries formed single currency zones, such as the Eurozone.

How do governments intervene to influence the exchange rate?

There are two basic strategies that governments and central banks can adopt to engineer changes in rates in floating or hybrid regimes.

  1. By buying and selling currencies in the forex market. For example, if the central bank wishes to engineer a depreciation in a currency it will use its own currency to purchase another currency, or several other currencies - releasing supply into the market. This may trigger a small fall in the exchange rate which may trigger other currency holders to sell. Once the desired rate is reached, the central bank will re-enter the market to buy its own currency, and halt further unwanted reductions.
  2. Secondly, the central bank (let us say, the Bank of England) can adjust the interest rate to influence the demand for assets in its own country (the UK). For example, if the Bank of England wishes sterling (the GB pound) to appreciate, it will increase the Bank of England base interest rate, which will increase the return on holding assets in sterling. This increased demand for UK assets increases the demand for sterling, which, ceteris paribus, will then appreciate.

These two strategies can be operated in tandem to help engineer changes to keep a currency within an agreed band or range.

Summary of advantages and disadvantages of different exchange rate regimes

Floating Fixed
Advantages Flexible adjustment to automatically achieve a balance of payments; governments are free to focus on other macroeconomic objectives. Certainty for traders; confidence; business can predict their costs and revenue; an environment suitable for investment.
Disadvantages Risk of speculation and uncertainty about future rates. Inflexible; may require periodic revaluations and devaluations; but may remain 'over' and 'under' valued; Uncertainty regarding the timing of intervention to re or de-value.

Hybrid systems use a combination of fixed and floating rates.

Examples of exchange rate regimes

Type of exchange rate

Description

Examples

No separate legal
tender

Countries have no legal tender of
their own. Shares currency with
other countries.

Ecuador
El Salvador, Panama
Zimbabwe

Currency board

This system exists where a country
only issues its own currency at a fixed
rate against another one.

East Caribbean Currency Unit
Bulgaria

Conventional fixed
peg

These systems peg a country’s
currency at a fixed rate to another
currency or basket of currencies.
The exchange rate is allowed to
fluctuate by a small amount,
usually less than 1%.

Barbados
Cameroon
Jordan
Saudi Arabia
Venezuela

Crawling peg and
‘crawl-like’ system

In this system, the currency is
adjusted when required following
changes in economic circumstances
such as inflationary pressures relative
to trading partners.

Argentina
Botswana
China

Managed floating

This is where the rate is allowed to
adjust and where no specific rate
is targeted, but where a particular
objective may be targeted, such as
trying to achieve a balance of
payments with trading partners.

Afghanistan
Brazil
Kenya
India

Free floating

This is where a national currency
or a ‘single’ currency is free to find its
own level against other currencies,
and where any intervention is simply
to remove volatility.

Australia
Chile
Euro-zone 19
Japan
UK
USA

Currency unions

Monetary union involves the agreement to share a single currency, which also means sharing the same central bank, and having a common interest rate.

While the Eurozone of the EU is the most well-known monetary union, there are others, including the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union (ECCU) where members shared the East Caribbean dollar, which is pegged to the US dollar. There are several other examples of countries sharing a common currency, but without close economic integration, including four countries that share the South African rand [South Africa, Namibia, Lesotho and Eswatini.]

The success of monetary unions depends upon the extent to which the member countries can converge. Without economic convergence, the currency zone will find it difficult to manage asymmetric shocks.

Optimal currency zones

The theory of ‘optimal currency zones’ - proposed by Canadian economist, Robert Mundell in 1961 - provides a set of criteria that would lead to successful monetary union between countries.

Mundell considered that an optimal currency area would have members who shared common macroeconomic goals, including low inflation and full employment, and a sustainable current account balance with other countries who have joined the area.

Specifically, Mundell identified some key attributes of an optimum currency area:

  1. Labour mobility between members of the area - which would reduce the need for flexible exchange rates [which no longer exist in a currency union].
  2. Capital mobility, which would help dampen the effects of any external shocks.
  3. Wage and price flexibility.
  4. Convergence in the economic (business) cycles of members

The effect of an asymmetric shock

The success of a monetary union depends upon how it deals with an asymmetric shock [which affects members differently] in the absence of the ability to reduce the exchange rate between two (or more) countries.

A currency union removes one of the key levers of macroeconomic policy – the ability of a country to alter its exchange rate to achieve an external balance. For a monetary union to be an 'optimal' currency area it must find other ways to deal with asymmetric shocks.

Assuming the shock results in an increase in demand for a good or service in country B, but a reduction in country A, the expected result is that prices (and wages) in B will rise, and fall in country A, creating a disequilibrium.

If the two countries have two separate currencies, then B's currency would appreciate (pushing up prices), and A's would depreciate (reducing prices), bringing the countries back towards equilibrium.

However, with a shared currency [and no possibility of exchange rate adjustments], labour and capital mobility are required.

Optimal currency area

The effect of the wage adjustment if that labour is attracted into country B from country A, shifting the supply curve for country B to the right, and country A to the left.

The result is that prices (and eventually wages) will readjust until there is equilibrium between the two countries once more. Hence, factor mobility is essential for a common currency area to be an 'optimal' one.

Of course, while a monetary union prevents individual members from operating their own individual monetary policy, they may be free to implement different taxes rates and fiscal policy, which can be used to help reduce the impact of asymmetric shocks.

Members of the Eurozone may call upon central funds to ease the impact of any asymmetric shock, as Greece did in 2010 - supported by the Eurozone's European Stability Mechanism (ESM), and the IMF.

Conclusion

In conclusion, on the benefits side a currency union removes the need to constantly manage exchange rates between members, with members free to focus on other objectives. The inability to alter rates also imposes discipline on members who cannot rely on devaluation or revaluation as a short term 'fix' to resolve domestic problems.

However, on the cost side this loss of ability to manipulate rates removes an automatic adjustment mechanism and means that members must be more disciplined in other areas, such as controlling public spending through 'austerity' measures. Although the effect of this may be short lived, they can have significant effects never-the-less.

Aggregate demand

More on aggregate demand and the AD curve.

Aggregate demand
Fiscal policy

How can fiscal policy influence aggregate demand?

Fiscal policy
Monetary policy

Is monetary policy effective at controlling inflation?

Monetary policy